When You Don't Have Answers for Your Team

Last fall, many of the leaders I coach spent weeks waiting out a federal shutdown. This year Congress avoided one in October, but the stopgap funding only runs through December 11, five weeks after the midterms. If your department or organization relies on federal dollars, your team is heading into another round of uncertainty.

Most leaders respond to this in one of three ways. They say nothing until they know something, they tell people not to worry, or they jump straight to the plan. All three come from a good place, and all three skip the part where people get to react.

Why Uncertainty is So Hard

Researchers at the University of Michigan followed more than 1,700 working adults for up to ten years. They found that ongoing worry about losing a job was more strongly linked to declining health than actually losing one. In one group, persistent job insecurity predicted poor health more strongly than smoking or high blood pressure (Burgard et al., 2009). Part of the reason, the researchers suggested, is that there's nothing to act on. You can't make a plan for something that may or may not happen.

That matches what I hear from staff. Bad news is hard, but people can plan around it. What leads to burnout is the ongoing uncertainty, especially when they can tell their leaders know more than they're saying.

Two Conversations

I coached a municipal leader, whom I’ll call Sam, through a season of major budget cuts. First, Sam's department was told to plan for cuts in the next fiscal year. Then they were told to plan for cuts in the current fiscal year too. Things changed twice in a few months, and Sam had to bring that news to a team that was already starting to feel burned out.

Sam's first instinct was the one most caring leaders have. Share the news, reassure people, and move quickly to options so no one would feel too concerned. But when people are still taking in hard news, they aren’t ready to problem-solve yet. And if we jump to solutions too quickly, people can walk away feeling like their concerns didn’t matter.

So I coached Sam to split it into two conversations. In the first, Sam shared what was known, what wasn't, and what could still change, and then listened. They didn’t give reassurance and didn’t move into problem-solving; they just gave space for people to say how they were feeling about it. The brainstorming came later, in a separate conversation, once people had a chance to digest the news.

Earlier this fall I wrote about an organization where leaders weren’t clear about changes that were coming, and the roundtables and updates started to feel like going through the motions. Moving too fast past people’s reactions can create a smaller version of the same problem. When reassurance comes before people feel heard, it doesn’t help them feel better. It can actually make them feel worse, because they start to wonder whether anyone really cares about how this is affecting them

Not All Uncertainty Is the Same

Prashant Bordia and his colleagues studied employees going through organizational change and found that uncertainty comes in three kinds: strategic (where is the organization going?), structural (how will the work be organized?), and job-related (what happens to me?). They also found that different things helped with each. Clear communication from leaders reduced strategic uncertainty. Structural and job-related uncertainty went down when people had a real say in decisions that affected them (Bordia et al., 2004).

Sam’s two conversations did both of these things. In the first, Sam was honest about what was known and what wasn’t and then listened to the team. In the second, the team got to weigh in on what mattered to them: which programs to protect, how cuts might change their workload, and what support they’d need. You don’t need to know what Congress will do in December to have both of these conversations.

Keeping the Heat Manageable

Ronald Heifetz describes part of a leader’s job as keeping stress at a productive level (Heifetz, 1994). Too little, and no one feels the urgency to take on hard work. Too much, and people shut down, get defensive, or start updating their resumes. You can’t control what happens in Washington. You can control whether your team hears news from you or secondhand, whether your messages are consistent, and whether you’re honest about what you don’t know.

Heifetz calls this creating a “holding environment,” enough trust and support that people can face something hard without falling apart. Sam’s first conversation did exactly that. It didn’t fix anything, but it made it possible for the team to work on the problem together afterward.

Want these insights sent straight to your inbox? Sign up for the newsletter below!

Previous
Previous

After tonight, someone is going to be disappointed. 

Next
Next

How to stand behind a decision when it gets hard