I’ve previously written about leading through funding uncertainty, when you have to make tough decisions before you have the answers you want. That has become the normal condition for most of the leaders I coach.
With email, Slack, AI and back-to-back video calls, things move fast. At that pace, it's easy to make a decision and move on without ever being clear on why you made it. That works fine until someone pushes back, or the decision doesn't play out the way you hoped. Then you start to doubt.
Conviction
Conviction isn't certainty that a decision will work. It's the confidence that you made the best decision you could with what you knew with a strong rationale. That difference matters, because outcomes are partly out of your control and other people's reactions are almost entirely out of your control.
It also matters because people judge decisions by how they turn out. Jonathan Baron and John Hershey gave people descriptions of decisions made under uncertainty, along with how things turned out. People rated the same decision as better thinking, and the decision maker as more competent, when the outcome was good, even when they said outcomes shouldn't count (Baron & Hershey, 1988). We do this to ourselves, too. Without conviction, a bad result or a tough reaction feels like proof you got it wrong, and the temptation is to reverse course, overexplain, or get stuck on the next decision.
With conviction, you can take the pushback without starting to spiral into doubt. Ronald Heifetz and Marty Linsky call this holding steady: staying with a hard decision long enough for people to work through their reactions, rather than backing off at the first sign of discomfort (Heifetz & Linsky, 2002). And when something does go wrong, conviction lets you ask a more useful question than "Was I wrong?" You can ask what you know now that you didn't know then, and what you'd do differently next time.
I worked with a leader, whom I’ll call Maria, who felt like she was constantly doubting her decisions. She felt that especially when she needed to hold a staff person accountable, go against what a staff person wanted, or disappoint the team in some way. Learning a simple process to develop conviction was a game changer for her. It helped her feel more confident even when there was pushback. It also allowed her to more openly review decisions that didn’t work, since she wasn’t doubting herself but rather analyzing the new information she had.
The I-Principles: Inspiration, Information, Influence
We’ve found it helpful to use something we call the The I-principles, as a way to build conviction before a decision, rather than trying to develop conviction afterward.
Inspiration: What am I trying to achieve, and why?
Start with the goal and the reason behind it. It sounds obvious, but it's the step most often skipped under pressure. Paul Nutt studied 356 decisions in public, private, and nonprofit organizations and found that about half of them failed (Nutt, 1999). The failures traced back to managers who jumped to a solution and cut short the search for alternatives. The decisions that held up started with leaders making the need for action clear at the beginning. When you know what you're trying to do, you have something to measure your options against, and something to come back to when the pushback starts.
Information: What do I need to know, and when will I know I have enough?
Next, figure out what you actually need to know, then go get it and test it. More isn't always better. Decide in advance what you need and when you'll stop. Name the two or three questions that would actually change your decision. Get answers from people who see the issue differently than you do, not just from people likely to agree. Then test your thinking. One useful tool is the premortem: imagine it's a year from now and the decision went badly, then list the reasons why (Klein, 2007). The research behind it found that imagining an outcome has already happened helps people come up with more explanations for it (Mitchell et al., 1989).
This is where the most leverage is. When Dan Lovallo and Olivier Sibony studied more than 1,000 major business decisions, they found that the quality of the decision process mattered six times more than the analysis behind it (Lovallo & Sibony, 2010). Their measures of a good process included whether the team openly discussed what was still uncertain and whether it heard views that contradicted the senior leader's.
Influence: How will I act on it?
Finally, decide how you'll put the decision into motion. Who needs to hear about it, from whom, and in what order? What will you say about why you made it, and what are you still unsure about? Being honest about the tradeoffs you weighed builds more trust than presenting a decision as obvious.
This is also when you decide how you'll learn from it. Write down why you made the call and what you expect to happen, and pick a time to look back. When you do, judge the decision by the quality of your thinking at the time, not only by the outcome, and look for what you'd change next time.
Conviction Isn't the Same as Being Stubborn
Conviction sometimes gets confused with refusing to change your mind. A leader who's digging in is protecting the decision. A leader with conviction is protecting the reasoning, and stays open to information that would change it. Because you named in advance what would change your mind, you can tell the difference between new information and pressure. New information is a reason to revisit. Pressure on its own usually isn't.
Make Time for Conviction
None of this works if every decision gets made in the moment. Back in June I wrote about resisting the urge to respond right away and committing to come back with a considered answer. Building conviction depends on that same pause. The instinct to act or speak immediately is strong, especially when someone is waiting on you. But speed often trades away the very thing you'll need later.
Reflection doesn't take long to pay off. Giada Di Stefano and her colleagues ran a field study with new call center employees in training. Those who spent the last 15 minutes of each day writing about what they'd learned scored more than 20% higher on the final assessment than those who didn't (Di Stefano et al., 2014). The point isn't that every decision needs a week. It's that a short, deliberate pause, built into your day, makes a real difference.
You also can't do this for everything. Most decisions are small and easy to reverse, and those should be made quickly. Save the full process for the ones that are hard to undo, that affect people's work or well-being, or that you know will draw pushback. For those, block the time on your calendar before you need it.
Want these insights sent straight to your inbox? Sign up for the newsletter below!