After tonight, someone is going to be disappointed. 

Today is Election Day. By tomorrow morning, some candidates will be celebrating and others will be conceding. The winners have something ahead of them that rarely gets said on election night: they're about to start disappointing people, including many who voted for them.

Last May we led a session for a group of mayors called Leading Through Uncertainty. One of the first things we looked at was the gap between what they promised in their campaigns and what they're actually able to deliver. Every mayor in the room recognized it. Most of them were living in it. One of the mayors said that she ran for office because she was so passionate about making her community more livable and affordable, and is now facing hard decisions that will anger the people who voted for her. 

Disappointment is Expected

You might assume the disappointment comes from broken promises. Mostly, it doesn't. Researchers who tracked more than 20,000 campaign pledges in 12 countries found that elected leaders keep most of their promises, yet voters believe they usually break them (Naurin, Royed & Thomson, 2019). Keeping your word won't protect you from letting people down.

The bigger reason is that the people who elect you want different things. One voter wants more housing built. Another wants the neighborhood to stay as it is. A business owner wants fewer rules. A tenant wants stronger protections. They all voted for you, and they all expect you to deliver.  Whatever you choose, someone who supported you loses something.

Ron Heifetz calls this kind of problem adaptive. There's no expert answer that makes the conflict go away, because the conflict is about what people value (Heifetz, 1994). The people who have the problem have to be part of working it out. Heifetz and Marty Linsky go a step further and describe leadership as "disappointing your own people at a rate they can absorb" (Heifetz & Linsky, 2002).

This is true for every leader, not just elected ones. But in government, expectations are louder and more public, and you got the job by telling people what you'd do.

What You Can Do

Two slides from that session drew a long silence: "You will get it wrong," and "Be prepared for the cost of leadership." The leaders who last are the ones who plan for that cost instead of hoping to avoid it.

Heifetz and Linsky offer three practices I come back to often with the leaders I coach. First, separate yourself from your role. Much of the anger aimed at a mayor is about the job and the losses people are facing, not about you as a person. You still listen to it. You just don't take it as a verdict on who you are.

Second, know the difference between allies and confidants. Allies share part of your agenda, but they have their own too. Confidants care more about you than about any issue, and you can fall apart in front of them. Many public leaders have plenty of allies and almost no confidants.

Third, find a place or routine where you can hear yourself think. When thousands of people want something from you, it gets hard to tell your own voice apart from theirs.

And watch for one trap. Many leaders respond to the pressure by trying to fix things themselves. It feels like the right thing to do, but it puts the work in the wrong place.

Bring People Into the Work

One of the slides I shared with the mayors said: "You cannot take the work off the group's shoulders and onto yours alone."

This is how disappointment becomes something people can handle. Tom Tyler's research shows that people are more likely to accept a decision that goes against them when they believe the process was fair (Tyler, 2007). Having a say matters a lot, even when it doesn't change the outcome (Lind, Kanfer & Earley, 1990). People can live with losing. What's much harder is feeling left out of the decision.

In practice, that means a few things. Ask people what they're worried about losing before you ask them to accept a tradeoff. Make room for them to grieve what's changing, and look for what you can carry forward so they still see themselves in the work. And agree together on how you'll work and how you'll hold each other, including you, accountable.

None of this makes the disappointment go away. It changes who's carrying it. Instead of one leader absorbing everyone's frustration, people work through the tradeoffs together and own the decisions with you.

Want these insights sent straight to your inbox? Sign up for the newsletter below!

Previous
Previous

Tell me the truth. I can take it.

Next
Next

When You Don't Have Answers for Your Team