Asking your team what they really think feels like a risk. It's actually one of the strongest moves a leader can make, as long as you're ready for what comes next.
A few weeks ago I wrote about launching our Fearless Organization Scan offering. Right now we're working with two teams whose leaders have decided to do something most leaders put off for as long as they can. They're asking their staff what they really think, through the Fearless Organization Scan and through focus groups and interviews with their teams.
I want to name how hard that is. People might tell you the meeting you thought went well didn't. They might name a decision they still don't trust, or a pattern in how you lead that you didn't know was visible. And you'll hear it in a form you can't easily dismiss.
Why We Avoid Hearing It
Most leaders don’t ask for feedback and their teams don’t give it directly. When Frances Milliken, Elizabeth Morrison, and Patricia Hewlin interviewed employees about speaking up, 85% said they'd been in situations where they felt unable to raise an issue with their supervisor, even though they thought it was important (Milliken et al., 2003). Among the reasons they gave were fear of being labeled negatively, fear of damaging relationships, and a sense that speaking up wouldn't change anything anyway.
Some of that fear isn't even based on how the leader actually behaves. James Detert and Amy Edmondson found that employees had unspoken rules about when speaking up is risky, and those beliefs predicted silence beyond what people reported about their own manager (Detert & Edmondson, 2011). People stay quiet because of what they assume will happen, not only because of what has happened.
Leaders contribute to this too, often without realizing it. Ethan Burris found that managers rated employees who spoke up in challenging ways as weaker performers than those who spoke up in supportive ways, and were less likely to endorse their ideas (Burris, 2012). The reflex to protect ourselves is strong and staff can pick up on that.
So on both sides of the relationship, there are good reasons to keep things polite. Leaders worry that asking will make them look weak or invite a pile-on. Staff worry that answering honestly will cost them.
You Won't Look as Bad as You Think
Here's what the research says about that leader's fear. Susan Ashford and Anne Tsui studied 387 managers in a public service agency and asked their supervisors, peers, and direct reports to rate them. Managers who sought out negative feedback were seen as more effective by all three groups. Managers who mostly sought positive feedback were seen as less effective (Ashford & Tsui, 1991). Asking for hard feedback made people think more of them, not less.
Similarly, in Zenger Folkman's research on more than 50,000 leaders, those in the bottom 10% for asking for feedback were rated, on average, around the 15th percentile in overall leadership effectiveness. Those in the top 10% were rated around the 86th percentile (Zenger & Folkman, 2021).
It makes sense when you think about it from the staff side. A leader who asks "What am I missing?" and means it is showing exactly the kind of security and openness people want to follow.
The Conversation Is Already Happening
Here's the part that’s easy to forget. When you ask for honest feedback, you're not creating hard conversations. You're bringing the ones people are already having into the room.
Those conversations are happening now, in the hallway, in the parking lot, in the text thread after the staff meeting. Phillip Clampitt calls this the meeting after the meeting, and he argues it's inevitable. People talk more candidly there because it feels lower risk than speaking up in the formal meeting. The only real choice a leader has is whether to be part of those conversations or not (Clampitt, 2024).
That's why asking is a power move, even when it doesn't feel like one. In the movie A Few Good Men, Jack Nicholson's colonel shouts the famous line, "You can't handle the truth!" He's convinced that keeping the truth out of the room is what protects his authority. It's the opposite. By the end of that scene, the truth comes out anyway, and he's lost control of it entirely.
A leader who says "Tell me the truth, I can take it" is making the opposite bet. The truth is already out there. When you invite it in, you get to hear it directly, respond to it, and shape what happens next. When you don't, it keeps being discussed without you, and people draw their own conclusions about why you never asked.
Then the Work Begins
Asking is the brave part. But it’s only the first step. Once people tell you what they really think, you've made an implicit promise that you’ll do something about it.
One of the reasons people gave for staying silent was a sense that nothing would change (Milliken et al., 2003). If you collect honest feedback and then don’t follow up, you confirm exactly that belief, and the next time you ask, you'll get the polite version. I wrote earlier this fall about an organization where well-designed feedback processes made trust worse, because nothing visible followed. The risk of asking isn't that people will say hard things. It's asking and then not acting.
The work after the feedback looks like this. Thank people for what they told you, especially the hard parts. Reflect back what you heard, in their words, so they know it landed. Watch your own reflex to explain or defend. Then be specific about what happens next: what you'll act on now, what you need to understand better, and what you can't change right now and why. And then follow through, visibly, on at least one thing soon enough that people can connect it to what they said.
That's where the two teams we're working with are headed next. The survey and the conversations were the hard first step. Now the leaders and their teams will look at what came up together and decide what to do about it.
Want these insights sent straight to your inbox? Sign up for the newsletter below!